Fossils shed light on the origins of curious ‘hobbit’ humans

Katie Hunt, CNN

(CNN) — A hobbit-size type of ancient quality that lived connected nan Indonesian land of Flores until astir 50,000 years agone baffles scientists successful respective ways.

First unearthed successful a startling discovery astir 21 years ago, Homo floresiensis, nan technological sanction for nan extinct species, challenged nan thought that quality improvement unfolded successful a neat statement from primitive to complex.

Experts don’t cognize why Homo floresiensis — nicknamed nan “hobbit” aft J.R.R. Tolkien’s fictional characters — evolved specified a mini assemblage yet lived comparatively recently, really it crossed heavy water to scope nan land of Flores, precisely wherever to spot this diminutive oddball connected nan quality family tree, aliases why it disappeared.

An study of recently described Homo floresiensis fossils published Tuesday successful nan diary Nature Communications attempts to reply immoderate of these questions astir nan mini human. The remains examined successful nan caller study see a part of a humerus — nan little half of nan precocious limb bony — and 2 teeth discovered astatine a tract known arsenic Mata Menge, 1 of only 2 places connected nan land of Flores wherever fossils of nan type person been found.

The study authors said their findings support an existing mentation that nan hobbits evolved their mini size a agelong clip agone and were astir apt a dwarfed type of Homo erectus, nan first ancient quality to time off Africa astir 1.9 cardinal years ago, pinch a assemblage size and upright gait akin to present-day humans. The remains of Homo erectus person been recovered connected nan Indonesian land of Java and elsewhere successful Asia arsenic good arsenic Africa.

The researchers judge Homo erectus became isolated connected nan land astir 1 cardinal years agone and underwent a melodramatic simplification successful assemblage size during a play of astir 300,000 years. Such a scaling down successful size happens to different animals connected distant islands successful consequence to constricted resources, nan study noted.

“Perhaps, location was nary request to beryllium large-bodied, which requires much nutrient and takes longer to turn and breed,” said lead study writer Yousuke Kaifu, a professor astatine nan University of Tokyo, via email. “The isolated land of Flores had nary mammalian predators and different hominin species, truthful small-body size was OK.”

Based connected nan estimated magnitude of nan bone, nan squad calculated nan tallness of its proprietor to beryllium 100 centimeters (about 3.3 feet) tall. Teeth recovered astatine nan aforesaid site, while smaller successful size, bore a “high grade of similarity” to Homo erectus teeth unearthed successful Java.

Digital microscopy of nan bone’s building indicated it belonged to an adult, alternatively than a child. The complete humerus would person been 21.1 centimeters to 22 centimeters (8.3 inches to 8.7 inches) successful length, nan smallest quality limb bony fossil ever found.

The sediment furniture containing nan fossils was dated successful erstwhile investigation to astir 700,000 years ago.

New Homo floresiensis revelations

Displayed is simply a recently described distal humerus part from nan extinct type Homo floresiensis. Researchers first excavated nan fossil successful 2013 astatine nan tract Mata Menge. | Yousuke Kaifu via CNN Newsource

This early hobbit was 6 centimeters (2.4 inches) shorter than nan original Homo floresiensis specimen, an almost complete skeleton recovered successful nan Liang Bua cave — astir 75 kilometers (46.6 miles) westbound of Mata Menge successful 2003 — and dated to astir 60,000 years ago. Liang Bua cave is nan only different spot wherever hobbit fossils person been found.

The disparity successful size betwixt nan 2 could constituent to earthy variation, arsenic seen wrong modern quality populations, nan authors noted. Overall, nan investigation suggested that nan hobbit species’ mini size remained remarkably changeless complete a agelong period.

The recently analyzed finds, on pinch different teeth, a jawbone and skull fragment, unearthed astatine nan aforesaid tract and antecedently described, correspond 4 hobbit individuals. Together pinch nan much caller Liang Bua fossils, they propose that nan mini humans were capable to thrive connected nan land contempt nan beingness of predators specified arsenic 3-meter-long (9.4-feet) Komodo dragons and crocodiles.

“The early melodramatic simplification and consequent stableness of assemblage size indicated that having a smaller assemblage size connected this isolated land was of use to nan endurance of these archaic humans,” nan study authors said successful a statement.

The hobbit, on pinch nan consequent find of 2 different small-bodied and small-brained hominins who lived comparatively precocious — Homo naledi successful South Africa and Homo luzonensis successful nan Philippines — and nan overmuch larger Denisovans, has led to a wider acceptance among paleoanthropologists that location person been galore divers type of human, including respective who coexisted pinch our ain species, Homo sapiens.

Before nan find of Homo floresiensis, galore experts successful quality improvement thought fundamentally only 1 type of quality had evolved done time, pinch location variation.

The ‘hobbit’ root story

Not each scientists agreed pinch nan study’s mentation that large-bodied Homo erectus was nan ancestor of Homo floresiensis and that nan hobbit represents a dwarfed type of Homo erectus, said coauthor Gerrit van den Bergh, a elder teacher astatine nan Centre for Archaeological Science astatine nan University of Wollongong successful Australia.

With its mini encephalon lawsuit and chimplike wristbones, nan hobbit whitethorn beryllium much intimately related to small-bodied hominins specified arsenic Homo habilis, only known from Africa, others person argued.

Matt Tocheri, Canada investigation chair successful quality origins astatine Lakehead University successful Ontario, said he wasn’t convinced that nan hobbit was a scaled-down Homo erectus.

“I work together that their grounds indicates that small-bodied hominins were coming connected Flores astatine slightest 700,000 years ago. But why does that person to mean that their contiguous ancestors that first arrived connected nan land were larger?” said Tocheri, who is besides a investigation subordinate successful nan Smithsonian Institution’s Human Origins Program.

“I deliberation this mobility remains unanswered and will proceed to beryllium a attraction of investigation for immoderate clip to come.”

Pictured present is nan Mata Menge excavation tract circa 2014 connected nan Indonesian land of Flores. | Gerrit van den Bergh via CNN Newsource

Van den Bergh said that nan hobbit remains unearthed astatine Mata Menge were recovered betwixt 2014 and 2016. However, nan humerus was surgery into fragments and not instantly recognized. One of nan study authors painstakingly put it backmost together later.

“The fossils hap successful difficult sandstone,” van den Bergh said via email. “(W)e are forced to usage metallic chisels and hammers to break up nan sediments, and truthful immoderate of nan fossils are recovered successful galore pieces.”

To resoluteness nan statement connected nan hobbit’s origins, hominin remains connected Flores making love further backmost to nan play erstwhile they arrived connected nan island, somewhat much than 1 cardinal years ago, would beryllium needed, some van den Bergh and Tocheri said.

When nan hobbit was first discovered, immoderate experts successful quality improvement based on nan bones were those of a modern quality pinch a maturation upset — specified arsenic microcephaly, a information that leads to an abnormally mini head, a mini assemblage and immoderate cognitive impairment. That assertion unleashed a fierce statement but has since mostly been rejected.

No motion of illness was recovered successful nan humerus, according to nan study.

“Every mini part of Homo floresiensis aliases immoderate different hominin is incredibly important,” Tocheri said. “These fossils are our model to nan shared evolutionary past of our species. Without them, we person nary thought what was happening successful nan past.”

RELATED | New ‘Lord of nan Rings’ movie coming successful 2026