Shell abandons North Slope oil leases, raising questions about the industry’s future in Alaska

4 months ago

ARTICLE AD BOX

Imagine, for a moment, that you’re nan caput of a publically traded lipid company.

In your area office, a squad of executives has travel to transportation you connected a new, perchance lucrative drilling opportunity. It’s successful a comparatively politically unchangeable country; nan section taxation authorities is reasonable, if not generous. Other companies person recovered immense deposits successful nan area, and your ain geologists are telling you that there’s apt a full batch of lipid successful nan ground. You’ve already leased nan area.

There’s 1 large problem, though: The task is successful nan Arctic, successful an undeveloped region of Alaska’s North Slope — and while it’s not successful heavy water, it’s a flimsy region offshore. Which intends drilling risks provoking lawsuits and permitting challenges from conservation groups, protests from section whaling captains, possibly moreover disruptions from ambiance activists astatine your adjacent shareholder meeting.

You telephone up nan heads of different multinational lipid companies that you sometimes activity pinch to spot if immoderate of them want to bargain a liking successful nan task and return nan lead connected drilling. But they each balk.

So, you return a pass, and manus backmost to nan authorities what could yet beryllium immoderate highly valuable leases. You’ll return your chances drilling location other — astir apt successful a region wherever you expect to beryllium capable to get nan lipid to marketplace sooner, earlier there’s excessively overmuch of a consequence of declining world lipid request amid take of renewable technologies.

Welcome to Alaska’s future. Or, really, its present.

The specifications are a spot fuzzy, but this communicative is not wholly hypothetical. Something for illustration it conscionable happened.

Earlier this month, Shell’s Houston-based U.S. limb said it would relinquish a group of lipid leases successful an area of nan North Slope, West Harrison Bay, that immoderate observers opportunity nan company’s ain geologists were salivating over. The leases were Shell’s past majority-owned properties successful nan state, pursuing its decision to springiness up a batch of national offshore leases successful 2016.

“As a erstwhile lipid institution feline for complete 40 years, I person sympathy for those guys successful Houston, because I knew it astir apt drove them crazy that their precocious guidance was truthful against it — and truthful frightened of nan European ambiance cultists,” said Anchorage Republican Rep. Tom McKay, who convened a legislative hearing about nan West Harrison Bay imaginable earlier this year.

McKay, a petroleum engineer, said successful an question and reply that he thinks different companies could still get nan leases astatine a authorities auction and drill for lipid themselves — including, potentially, an upstart player, Narwhal LLC, that has bought up surrounding acreage.

But Narwhal lacks Shell’s tremendous financial wherewithal — a important plus erstwhile nan costs of drilling wells successful distant parts of nan North Slope tin apical $100 million.

Other manufacture players opportunity that Shell’s exit from nan authorities is an important and unsettling awesome of nan economical early for oil-dependent Alaska: As nan world looks toward lower-carbon power sources successful consequence to world warming, immoderate of nan state’s hard-to-tap petroleum prospects are becoming little attractive.

The exit of Shell — 1 of nan first awesome companies to run successful Alaska — follows nan departure of different awesome companies from nan state, including BP in 2020.

“A batch of worldly is coming together that suggests decreased finance successful remote, Arctic areas for lipid and gas. Alaska activity has to understand this worldly is happening,” said Mark Myers, a erstwhile authorities earthy resources commissioner who besides erstwhile led nan U.S. Geological Survey. “Worldwide events are overcoming america faster than we tin negociate it. Shell’s consequence should not beryllium seen arsenic a one-off.”

The extremity of lipid and state is still acold disconnected successful Alaska, wherever taxes and royalties from nan industry amount to somewhat much than one-third of nan authorities government’s unrestricted revenue.

Two immense caller lipid projects are presently nether building connected nan North Slope, and could collectively boost Alaska’s wide accumulation by immoderate 50%.

But nan caller Pikka development, now owned by Australian institution Santos, was delayed for years amid concerns from investors astir backing a task successful nan Arctic. And ConocoPhillips’ caller Willow task has faced a slew of lawsuits and intense, broad opposition from conservation groups and ambiance advocates.

Shell acquired its West Harrison Bay leases successful 2012 — nan aforesaid twelvemonth nan institution began a much higher-profile drilling quest in nan Chukchi and Beaufort seas offshore of Alaska. That unsuccessful multiyear campaign, successful national waters, was marked by the wreck of 1 of Shell’s offshore drilling rigs.

The drilling yet costs nan institution $7 billion, but ne'er produced a tube of lipid for sale.

In nan aftermath of that failure, and amid fierce lobbying by activists against Arctic lipid development, nan company said a fewer years later that it would not prosecute immoderate caller distant exploration leases successful nan region.

But it softly held connected to its 125 quadrate miles successful West Harrison Bay, successful nan authorities waters conscionable offshore of nan National Petroleum Reserve – Alaska.

The deposit is northbound of ConocoPhillips’ Willow project, and conscionable to nan westbound of Santos’ Pikka development. And Shell, in correspondence with nan Alaska Department of Natural Resources successful 2020, said it had identified respective imaginable lipid and state accumulations and prospects.

But to corroborate nan beingness of commercially viable lipid deposits, Shell would person to drill wells. In 2020, nan institution took an first measurement successful that direction, merging its 18 leases into a azygous unit.

But Shell, in its correspondence with nan state, indicated that it did not want to drill nan wells itself. Instead, it was searching for different business to bargain a liking successful nan leases, return connected immoderate of nan “risk and cost” associated pinch nan area’s improvement and statesman an exploration campaign.

Shell said its efforts were hindered by nan coronavirus pandemic. Through September 2023, it told nan authorities that it was still having “ongoing discussions pinch its world contacts,” but finally, earlier this month, the institution said it had been “unable to unafraid a suitable co-owner” and would surrender nan West Harrison Bay leases.

“The Arctic is specified a reliable optic for a ample world lipid company. You can’t person an yearly gathering without personification saying, ‘Increase your profits, but by God, don’t do it successful nan Arctic,’” said a personification acquainted pinch nan decision, who requested anonymity owed to nan sensitivity of nan deliberations. They added: “It’s not that there’s nary lipid there.”

In an emailed consequence to questions, a Shell spokeswoman, Cynthia Babski, did not straight place nan obstacles to uncovering a partner, saying only that nan institution had been “actively seeking a co-owner and operator” for respective years but yet was unsuccessful.

Babski declined to reside McKay’s comments astir nan “climate cultists,” and besides did not straight reply a mobility astir why Shell did not activity to waste nan leases alternatively than return them to nan state.

“After discussions pinch nan Alaska Department of Natural Resources and different stakeholders, Shell chose to terminate nan portion and relinquish nan leases,” she said.

That prime could person repercussions for Narwhal, a small, privately owned lipid institution whose mostly stakeholder is simply a Texas-based family partnership, according to firm filings pinch nan state.

Narwhal’s leaders see a erstwhile Shell worker who worked connected nan company’s West Harrison Bay improvement plans. And Narwhal owns much than a twelve of its ain leases successful nan bay that situation nan area formerly leased by Shell — though it besides hasn’t done immoderate drilling.

For nan past 2 years, Narwhal has pushed Republican Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s management to unit Shell into advancing its drilling efforts successful West Harrison Bay. It also said successful 2022 that Shell had “summarily dismissed” astatine slightest a half-dozen of Narwhal’s general proposals, since 2016, to either jointly drill for lipid successful nan area, aliases to bargain Shell’s leases outright.

Narwhal officials did not respond to requests for comment, and Babski declined to remark connected Narwhal’s assertions. But now, if Narwhal wants to bargain nan leases formerly held by Shell, it will person to triumph them astatine an upcoming auction held by nan earthy resources department, which officials opportunity could hap arsenic soon arsenic later this year.

“The section understands this area to beryllium highly prospective,” said John Crowther, nan department’s lawman commissioner.

One awesome problem for immoderate lipid institution that ends up uncovering lipid successful West Harrison Bay is getting it out.

The onshore surrounding nan nearshore leases relinquished by Shell is each wrong nan National Petroleum Reserve, wherever nan Biden administration just finalized caller limits on lipid and state infrastructure and development.

Industry observers opportunity that building a caller pipeline from West Harrison Bay crossed nan petroleum reserve and eastbound to link backmost to nan trans-Alaska pipeline could beryllium difficult, if not impossible, to unafraid biology permits for. Crowther and others suggested that possibly a pipeline could enactment offshore, successful authorities waters, until it connects backmost to state-owned land, wherever permitting is much industry-friendly.

The large mobility now is whether immoderate institution tin unafraid nan finance needed to return up specified challenges.

Myers, nan erstwhile earthy resources commissioner, said he thinks that permitting and governmental impediments person go an expanding problem for Arctic projects, fixed that lipid developments successful different areas tin often beryllium brought online much quickly.

“You person to look astatine nan clip it takes you to licence and develop, moreover if you’re successful. How does that play into nan timing of erstwhile we commencement decreasing lipid request successful nan world?” he said. “Before, if I beryllium connected it for 20 years, it’s worthy hanging onto because there’s ever going to beryllium a marketplace for it successful nan future. Now, lipid is systematically being replaced for galore of its uses. You’re looking astatine a different opportunity successful nan future.”

Myers is worried capable astir Alaska’s post-oil economical early that he’s currently investigating whether nan authorities mightiness clasp economically valuable underground deposits of a carbon-free fuel: hydrogen.

Dunleavy, nan governor, is besides hosting a sustainable power convention this week. But immoderate lawmakers stay profoundly skeptical astir nan request to reposition nan state’s economy.

McKay, nan Republican authorities representative, noted that nan Alaska Legislature just passed a bill that could thief prolong nan state’s lipid and state manufacture by allowing companies to sequester c contamination underground.

He besides dismissed federal conclusions and the broad technological consensus about nan far-reaching and worsening effects of ambiance change.

“It’s each emotion. You can’t walk trillions of dollars connected thing that’s based connected emotion,” he said. “I’m conscionable not fresh to surrender our lipid and state business.”

Nathaniel Herz welcomes tips at natherz@gmail.com or (907) 793-0312. This article was originally published in Northern Journal, a newsletter from Herz. Subscribe astatine this link.

Source Alaska Public